[LINK] : ‘Alarm bells ringing’

Marghanita da Cruz marghanita at ramin.com.au
Tue Aug 18 09:10:52 AEST 2026


On 8/17/26 18:42, Kim Holburn wrote:

> On Monday, 17 August 2026 12:45:08 AEST Kim Holburn wrote:
>
>>>> /Suppose a driverless train hits a collapsed tunnel section under 
>>>> the Harbour due to subsidence or earthquake, killing all aboard. 
>>>> />>/No need for driverless in that sentence. It doesn't add 
>>>> anything to the "argument". /
>> True, but it's a hypothetical scenario intended to illustrate the 
>> difficulty of assigning legal responsibility and even governing per 
>> se when few, if any, in most western governments understand science 
>> in any depth. 
>
> Well, leave the driverless part out, It's too try hard.
>
>> My response was NOT intended to be a critique of tunnel engineering, 
>> climate change, geology, or world history.
>
> But it was just that and a shifting of all blame to the government.
>
>>>> /If such an event happened we could not possibly say it was a 
>>>> direct result of climate change. But it's equally true that the _risk_ 
> >>> of such a scenario will be increased substantially by climate 
> change. />/> None of that appears to be in any way, a logical argument /
>> Really?  Why exactly? 
> Prove the risk of a tunnel collapse is in any way due to climate 
> change or that it hasn't already been factored in in the design of 
> said system.
>
>>>> /So is the NSW Government off the hook then, or not? Where does the 
>>>> Precautionary Principle reverse the onus from the Proposer to 
> the Approver in this context? And how does the "Duty of Care" 
> principle apply to those in power? />/> I don't see how we can blame 
> the government for accidents. We can blame them for responses, risk 
> analysis and preparedness. /
>> My point exactly.
>
> They already prepare in so many ways for disasters and NSW has a 
> pretty good record compared with many, many other countries.  What is 
> your point?
>
> You could do better?
>
> Don't complain, volunteer to help.
>
>>>> /In my personal view, these situations will not change until those 
>>>> in power suffer personal risk when ignoring good advice for 
> short-term political kudos. />/> Since they make the rules, it's not 
> going to happen /
>> True again, for the most part.  However the Electorate does have a 
>> say, and nothing will concentrate a pollies mind more than the 
>> prospect of a majority of Teals, Greens, and Independents at the next 
>> State election. 
> Or PHON?
>
>> IMO that may well happen because the aforementioned Electorate has 
>> lost trust in governments. 
> Really nothing to do with your driverless train hyperthetical.
>
>> _DavidL_
>
> BTW, I only seem to see half your posts.  (Not a complaint.)

Unintended consequences!

In reality, designers should have more accident data than the public.

m

-- 
Marghanita da Cruz
Telephone: 0414-869202
Email:  marghanita at ramin.com.au
Website: http://ramin.com.au



More information about the Link mailing list