[LINK] No cash for phone alert system

[Birch, Jim]

Without trying to pre-empt the inquiry that will do a real analysis, I
think the whole argument about a warning system is completely misplaced.
The basic problem is the speed and ferocity of the fire and the
proximity of houses to forest.  I've spoken to people here in Tasmania
who remember the '67 bushfires when small towns were wiped out and never
seen again.  Unfortunately the memory of these events doesn't spread far
enough or last long enough.

The conditions of the Victorian fire event - housing adjacent or in
forests loaded with dry fuel, low humidity, high temperatures and very
strong winds - can produce unstoppable wildfire that travels at high
speeds, spotting kilometres ahead of the main fire and cutting off
escape routes.  The radiant heat levels and force of the ember attack
make firefighting impossible and houses to burn so quickly that they may
not provide a temporary refuge from the fire front.

People may have seen a small fire or two but they apparently don't
understand how fast and lethal these conditions are.  A better way to
spend money would be an education process with regular topups, coupled
with a planning system that requires realistic fireproofing and/or
shelters for people live in proximity to forests.

I received this forward from a friend of my mother, Derek Dixon, that
makes the point graphically:

Derek Dixon wrote:

Sent: Friday, February 13, 2009 7:02 AM
Subject: (no subject)


*THEY warn you it comes fast. But the word "fast" doesn't come anywhere
near describing it.*

It comes at you like a runaway train. One minute you are preparing. The
next you are fighting for your home. Then you are fighting for your
life. But it is not minutes that come between. It's more like seconds.
The firestorm moves faster than you can think, let alone react.

For 25 years, we had lived on our hilltop in St Andrews, in the hills
northeast of Melbourne.

You prepare like they tell you every summer.

You clear. You slash. You prime your fire pump. For 25 years, fires were
something that you watched in the distance.

Until Saturday.

We had been watching the massive plume of smoke from the fire near
Kilmore all afternoon; secure in the knowledge it was too far away to
pose a danger.

Then suddenly there is smoke and flames across the valley, about a
kilometre to the northwest, being driven towards you by the wind. Not
too bad, you think.

I rush around the side of the house to start the petrol-powered fire
pump to begin spraying the house, just in case.  When I get there, I
suddenly see flames rushing towards the house from the west. The tongues
of flame are in our front paddock, racing up the hill towards us across
grass stubble I thought safe because it had been slashed.

In the seconds it takes me to register the flames, they are into a small
stand of trees 50m from the house. Heat and embers drive at me like an
open blast furnace. I run to shelter inside, like they tell you, until
the fire front passes.  Inside are my wife, a 13-year-old girl we care
for, and a menagerie of animals "rescued" over the year by our
veterinary-student daughter.

They call it "ember attack". Those words don't do it justice.  It is a
fiery hailstorm from hell driving relentlessly at you. The wind and
driving embers explore, like claws of a predator, every tiny gap in the
house. Embers are blowing through the cracks around the closed doors and
windows.

We frantically wipe at them with wet towels. We are fighting for all we
own. We still have hope. The house begins to fill with smoke. The smoke
alarms start to scream. The smoke gets thicker. I go outside to see if
the fire front has passed. One of our two cars under a carport is
burning. I rush inside to get keys for the second and reverse it out
into an open area in front of the house to save it. That simple act will
save our lives. I rush back around the side of the house, where plastic
plant pots are in flames. I turn on a garden hose.

Nothing comes out.

I look back along its length and see where the flames have melted it. I
try to pick up one of the carefully positioned plastic buckets of water
I've left around the house. Its metal handle pulls away from the melted
sides.
I rush back inside the house. The smoke is much thicker. I see flames
behind the louvers of a door into a storage room, off the kitchen. I
open the door and there is a fire burning fiercely.

I realise the house is gone. We are now fighting for our lives.

We retreat to the last room in the house, at the end of the building
furthest from where the firestorm hit. We slam the door, shutting the
room off from the rest of the house. The room is quickly filling with
smoke.
It's black, toxic smoke, different from the superheated smoke outside.
We start coughing and gasping for air. Life is rapidly beginning to
narrow to a grim, but inevitable choice. Die from the toxic smoke
inside. Die from the firestorm outside.

The room we are in has french doors opening on to the front veranda.
Somewhere out of the chaos of thoughts surfaces recent media bushfire
training I had done with the CFA. When there's nothing else, a car might
save you.

I run the 30 or 40 steps to the car through the blast furnace. I wrench
open the door to start the engine and turn on the airconditioning, as
the CFA tells you, before going back for the others.
 
The key isn't in the ignition. Where in hell did I put it? I rush back
to the house. By now the black, toxic smoke is so thick I can barely see
the others. Everyone is coughing. Gasping. Choking. My wife is calling
for one of our two small dogs, the gentle, loyal Gizmo, who has fled in
terror.
I grope in my wife's handbag for her set of car keys. The smoke is so
thick I can't see far enough to look into the bag. I find them by touch,
thanks to a plastic spider key chain our daughter gave her as a joke.
Our lives are saved by a plastic spider. I tell my wife time has run
out. We have to get to the car. The choices have narrowed to just one
option, just one slim chance to live.

Clutching the second of our two small dogs, we run to the car. I feel
the radiant heat burning the back of my hand. The CFA training comes
back again. Radiant heat kills.
The three of us are inside the car. I turn the key. It starts. We turn
on
the airconditioning and I reverse a little further away from the burning
building. The flames are wrapped around the full fuel tank of the other
car and I worry about it exploding.

We watch our home - our lives, everything we own - blazing fiercely just
metres away. The heat builds. We try to drive down our driveway, but
fallen branches block the way. I reverse back towards the house, but my
wife warns me about sheets of red-hot roofing metal blowing towards us.
I drive back down, pushing the car through the branches. Further down
the 400m drive, the flames have passed. But at the bottom, trees are
burning. We sit in the open, motor running and airconditioner turned on
full. Behind us our home is aflame. We calmly watch from our hilltop,
trapped in the sanctuary of our car, as first the house of one
neighbour, then another, then another goes up in flames. One takes an
agonisingly slow time to go, as the flames take a tenuous grip at one
end and work their way slowly along the roof. Another at the bottom of
our hill, more than a 100 years old and made of imported North American
timber, explodes quickly in a plume of dark smoke. All the while the car
is being buffeted and battered by gale-force winds and bombarded by a
hail of blackened material. It sounds like rocks hitting the car.

The house of our nearest neighbour, David, who owns a vineyard, has so
far escaped. But a portable office attached to one wall is billowing
smoke.
I leave the safety of the car and cross the fence. Where is the CFA, he
frantically asks. With the CFA's help, perhaps he can save his house.
What's their number, he asks me. I tell him we had already rung 000,
before our own house burnt. Too many fires. Too few tankers. I leave him
to his torment. I walk back towards our own house in a forlorn hope that
by some miracle our missing dog may have survived in some unburned
corner of the building.

Our home, everything we were, is a burning, twisted, blackened jumble.
Our missing dog, Gizmo, Bobby our grumpy cockatoo, Zena the rescued
galah that spoke Greek and imitated my whistle to call the dogs, our
free-flying budgie nicknamed Lucky because he escaped a previous
bushfire, are all gone. Killed in the inferno that almost claimed us as
well. I return to the car and spot the flashing lights of a CFA tanker
through the blackened trees across the road. We drive down the freeway,
I pull clear more fallen branches and we reach the main road. I walk
across the road to the tanker and tell them if they are quick they might
help David save his house. I still don't know if they did. We stop at a
police checkpoint down the hill. They ask us where we've come from and
what's happening up the road. I tell them there's no longer anything up
the road.

We stop at the local CFA station in St Andrews. Two figures sit hunched
in chairs, covered by wet towels for their serious burns. More
neighbours. We hear that an old friend, two properties from us, is
missing. A nurse wraps wet towels around superficial burns on my wife's
leg and my hand. We drive to my brother's house, which fate had spared,
on the other side of St Andrews.

The thought occurs to me, where do you start when you've lost
everything, even a way to identify yourself. Then I realise, of course,
it doesn't matter. We escaped with our lives. Just. So many others
didn't.


CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER

The information in this transmission may be confidential and/or protected by legal professional privilege, and is intended only for the person or persons to whom it is addressed. If you are not such a person, you are warned that any disclosure, copying or dissemination of the information is unauthorised. If you have received the transmission in error, please immediately contact this office by telephone, fax or email, to inform us of the error and to enable arrangements to be made for the destruction of the transmission, or its return at our cost. No liability is accepted for any unauthorised use of the information contained in this transmission. If the transmission contains advice, the advice is based on instructions in relation to, and is provided to the addressee in connection with, the matter mentioned above. Responsibility is not accepted for reliance upon it by any other person or for any other purpose.